Sunday, November 12, 2006

Microfinance: for profit or not for profit?

The awarding of the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize to Muhammed Yunus put the microcredit/microfinance concept onto the front pages. Those of us who see global poverty as humanity's most-fundamental issue were thrilled to see the issue get such media attention, and you can count me among those who have long been excited by microcredit. Then the October 30 issue of The New Yorker made public a hot theoretical debate about whether microcredit works best in a non-profit or a for-profit form.

Grameen Bank, Yunus' organization, is a non-profit which initially used grants and soft loans for its work; now it is almost self-sustaining. (It's an example of an institution that is openly and unapologetically biased in favor of women, on the grounds that as Yunus says, women are more responsible about re-paying the loans and poor families benefit more when the women control the money; whether that practice would be legally sustainable in the western world is debatable.) Now a group of socially-minded entrepeneurs, who see Yunus as a well-meaning example of founder's syndrome, think that microfinance can reach truly global scale plausibly only as a for-profit sector.

They seem to think that more contributions could be pried loose from the western world's newly-wealthy entrepeneurs to for-profit microfinance funds than to non-profits, an idea which reflects an outdated view of the non-profit sector and which isn't supported by the current flood of huge contributions being made towards this movement. Perhaps more relevantly, they think that commercial enterprises can tap the capital markets for investment funds at a scale that dwarfs even the stunning scale of philanthropy in today's world.

Yunus and his supporters recoil from that in part on philosophical grounds, feeling that profit as a required payoff for helping the poor is vaguely immoral. More tangibly, they worry about mission drift: that commercial competitive pressure inevitably would mean that only the less-poor or the working poor would be considered reasonable risks for loans. One response is that adding working-class customers is simply a way to stay afloat so as to keep lending to the really poor, but that flies in the face of Yunus' core argument that the poor can be reliable borrowers even at high rates of interest.

Hmm, all good questions...is it necessarily an either/or choice? We have both non-profit and for-profit hospitals, ditto theaters, also some other important sectors -- is that diversity of structures and motivations not positive in some important ways?

Another thought is that this seems like a perfect fit for non-profits to leverage the foundation sector's increasing interest in mission-related investment, where part of a foundation's endowment can be invested at higher-than-normal risk or lower-than-normal return provided the investments have a mission purpose. Hopefully somebody is talking seriously about this with some of the multi-billion foundations like Gates, Ford, et al.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi

Check out
www.traidmark.org
for explanations about donating profit to fund innovation.

Ed

Anonymous said...

Hola, Interesante, no va a continuar con este artнculo?

Anonymous said...

Actually Grameen Bank is a commercial bank, albeit not on a traditional model. Grameen Foundation and Grameen Fund (as well as other branches of Grameen) are nonprofits.

Anonymous said...

Keep on working, great job!

Feel free to surf to my web blog raspberry ketone reviews

Anonymous said...

For individuals on the go, thin wallets are all the rage.
What about iphone 4S which took the year 2011 by storm,
globally? They don't want to be connected with only on AT&T community.


Have a look at my web site: Cydia - gorbunam.net -

Anonymous said...

Good day! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group?

There's a lot of people that I think would really apprdeciate youur content.
Please let me know. Thank you

Revew my weblog ... Venus Factor Review - http://www.reddit.com/r/fightweight/comments/26na37/venus_factor_review/ -

Anonymous said...

It allows companies to acquire reputation and crddibility that sustains
and ctegorizes their products increasing their demand. Post your ads inn
cities which will brig the highest amounts of views for your
merchandise or services. From your Blogger or Blogsot blog (the two sites are synonymous) select the 'Settings' button.

Also visit my page :: facebook marketing

Anonymous said...

Fantastic blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers?
I'm hoping to start my own site soon but I'm a little lost on everything.
Would you suggest starting with a free platform like Wordpress or go for
a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I'm completely
confused .. Any ideas? Appreciate it!

Visit my blog post: google (google.com)

Anonymous said...

Simply desire to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your submit is
just great and that i could think you are an expert on this
subject. Well along with your permission let me to grasp your RSS
feed to stay up to date with forthcoming post. Thank you a million and please continue the enjoyable work.


My web site - Licensed Tile Roofs 33189

Anonymous said...

ԝas listed by Forbes in its 2010 edition as thе гіchest man in the Philippines and was honored by the prestigious magazine in 2009 for being one of
the Filipino Heroes of Phіlanthropy. The othеr ƿroblem ѡith doіng ab exercises on the Beаn is
that it allows you to rock back and forth, creating momentum.
Will also use Hodir's Protective Gaze which will sometimes
save a player from death by encasing them in a block of
іce.

Here is my page :: restore my vision pdf

pendekarmuda said...

thanks, nice blog and this good information . . . .